I turned 50 a few days ago.
I simultaneously want the whole world to know and absolutely no one to know. I want to be the proudest 50-year-old baddie on the planet and also want everyone to think I’m 45. I want all the privileges of wisdom and age and also to not need reading glasses.
BOTH THINGS CAN BE TRUE AT THE SAME TIME.
BTCBTATST is an unfortunate acronym for what has, for better or worse, become something of a personal motto. And not just about turning 50.
I have a friend I love deeply, and I struggle with some of the things she's willing to accept in pursuit of her professional ambitions. BTCBTATST.
Sometimes you have to uphold an HR policy because you’ve applied it consistently to everyone else, but it feels crummy because you really, really want to make an exception for a particular person and their circumstances. BTCBTATST.
I spent 11 years working for someone who I trusted and respected, someone who treated me well. I later learned that he caused serious harm to other people. Both things can be true, but my positive experience with him doesn't diminish or excuse the harm he caused. And I've had to ask myself whether my closeness to him played any role in enabling his behavior.
That last one is where this philosophy really took hold for me. It's also where I learned that holding two truths at once can be deeply uncomfortable, especially when one of those truths forces you to question yourself. A much heavier example, obviously, than wanting everyone to know it’s my birthday while secretly hoping they’ll mistake me for someone five years younger.
I Care About Your Nuance
Once, a colleague and I were in a meeting with a crisis communications company, trying to explain that what had happened wasn’t so black and white. The woman across the table listened to us, leaned in, and said, “No one gives a shit about your nuance.”
Well, I do give a shit about your nuance.
I hold this concept so dearly; it’s become so much a part of my ethos that I actually had to tell Claude the other day to stop overusing it. It had worked “Both things can be true: you may be nervous about this, and it may go better than you expect,” into a “how-to prepare for mediation” guide I was creating. I mean, technically yes, Claude, but I’m not sure it’s necessary to get into my philosophy of the complexity of the human experience to say that the mediation might go okay.
Moving on. This idea has become a pretty fundamental part of how I understand people and how I try to move through the world. I truly believe that no one is the worst thing they’ve ever done, a sentiment I first heard from Bryan Stevenson (if you haven’t read Just Mercy, I highly recommend it). I believe that people contain multitudes, that we are capable of doing great things and terrible things, and that our experiences of someone can be different without either of us necessarily being wrong.
Some of you may know that I work with a volunteer-run pen pal collective that initiates and supports meaningful connections between people inside and outside of prison in ways that can transform us all. The collective is rooted in the belief that no one is disposable, a value that is deeply important to me. And, not to feed a fed horse here, I can also understand why some people might struggle with that belief.
I think we need to get more comfortable holding these kinds of conflicting truths, especially when we’re responsible for leading other people. Because the people we lead are every bit as complicated as we are, even if we’d sometimes prefer they weren’t.
He Told His Best Friend. Does That Mean We Can’t Trust Him?
Here’s an example that I think illustrates the idea well.
A VP of Operations resigned, and the founder and leadership team decided to promote the Director of Operations into the role. They shared the exciting news with him on Friday, asking him to keep it confidential until they announced the VP’s departure on Monday.
Over the weekend, the director told the executive chef, and when the founder found out, he was understandably angry. “How can we trust him? I told him not to tell anyone!”
I understood his reaction. This was a senior leader who had been given very clear instruction about something sensitive, and he hadn’t followed it. That's a legitimate concern, particularly when you’re about to put even more responsibility in someone’s hands.
But I also reminded him that the director and executive chef had opened three restaurants together! Long days, late nights, the weeks when your coworkers see you more than your family does. These two had been through that together multiple times. They’re besties. Of course, he wanted to share the excitement with his longtime partner in crime!
The founder was looking at what happened and questioning if he could trust this person. I wanted him to consider the whole picture before reaching that conclusion.
Both things can be true. He broke an agreement, and he can still be a trustworthy person. He can be ready for this promotion and have made a not-so-great choice (and could probably benefit from some coaching).
What Else Might Be True?
I’ve noticed that when I offer people my BTCBTATST philosophy, it can land as both deeply validating and wholly unsatisfying. Sometimes it’s a relief to have someone acknowledge that two contradictory feelings or experiences can coexist. Other times, people are looking for an answer, and telling them that two things can be true doesn’t exactly give them one.
I get it. There are plenty of situations in leadership where you have to make a decision, even when you can see and understand both sides. You may wish you could make an exception for someone, but you still have to uphold a policy. You may understand exactly why an employee behaved the way they did, but you still have to address the impact of their behavior on the team.
But not every contradiction requires a verdict. I don't need to decide that everyone I've loved or admired is either good or bad. I can accept that someone I care about has done things I deeply disagree with, even if that's uncomfortable.
I think that willingness to sit with complexity is an important part of leading people well.
So I’d offer, the next time someone on your team does something disappointing, or makes a decision you can't understand, I'd encourage you to ask yourself one question before deciding what it says about them:
What else might be true?
I just think we owe it to the people we lead to consider the whole picture before deciding who they are. I've found that making room for those other truths helps me uphold my values, particularly when I'm dealing with people whose actions have disappointed me. I can hold them accountable, enforce consequences when necessary, and still recognize that what they've done isn't the entirety of who they are.
And if I can make room for being thrilled to turn 50 and also a little horrified by it, surely I can make room for the contradictions in the people around me.
As you may have guessed, I could talk about this for hours. These aren't always comfortable conversations, but I'm up for them if you are. And if you're wrestling with the challenge of holding competing truths about people or situations at work, reach out. I'd love to talk about it. I’m here to give you both wholly validating and completely unsatisfying support!

